Free: my Travel Checklist, so you never miss something again →New guide: How to choose a work tote that lastsPacking for a trip? Get the checklist I've used for 30 years →Travel Tales: the carry-on that wasn'tWeekend, business or long-haul? Get the checklist for your trip →Free: my Travel Checklist, so you never miss something again →New guide: How to choose a work tote that lastsPacking for a trip? Get the checklist I've used for 30 years →Travel Tales: the carry-on that wasn'tWeekend, business or long-haul? Get the checklist for your trip →
Editorial standards

How we test and recommend bags

Every recommendation on BagLife follows the same process. Here's exactly what happens before a bag or a bag type makes it into a guide.

  1. Step 1

    Research the category

    We map the materials, price bands and construction methods, and talk to makers and repairers about what fails first.

  2. Step 2

    Measure everything

    Interior dimensions, empty weight, handle drop and strap length, measured by us rather than copied from product pages.

  3. Step 3

    Run the construction checks

    Stitch density, handle anchors, edges, base, hardware and lining: the six checks from our buying checklist.

  4. Step 4

    Carry it for real

    Where we test specific bags, we carry them on real commutes and trips, loaded with what people actually carry.

  5. Step 5

    Learn from what breaks

    Thirty years of snapped handles, burst zips and worn-out corners shape the advice in every guide.

  6. Step 6

    Update regularly

    Guides are reviewed every quarter. The "Updated" date at the top of each guide tells you when.

Reading our ratings

What the meters mean

RatingMeaning
Exceptional. Expect 10+ years of daily use with normal care and repairs.
Very good. Several years of daily use; may need a repair along the way.
Good. Fine for regular use, but shorter-lived or harder to repair.
Fair. Occasional use only. We rarely recommend at this level.